Passenger Pick of the Month

Agua Restaurant & Lounge

Beach Resort

In just over three years Agua has quickly established itself as one of Cayman’s best restaurants.  After winning the overall top pick in January’s 2012 Taste of Cayman Agua got awarded with the 3 Diamonds from the Triple A Guide and the Award of Excellence from the Wine Spectator for his extensive wine list.  

Italian owners Cristiano Vincentini and Walter Fajette became great friends while working together at Calypso Grill, and then achieved their dream of creating a successful restaurant on Seven Mile beach.  As this month’s Passenger Pick of the Month, we wanted to learn more about the story behind Agua, so recently we caught up with owners Walter and Cristiano.

PP: So…two Italian guys open a restaurant, but this doesn’t feel like a typical Italian restaurant.  Tell us about it.

WF: In planning Agua, we saw that there are so many Italian restaurants on the island, and many of the menu items are the same.  But we wanted to do something different.  So, even though we are both Italians, we decided to call our restaurant a very “un” Italian name and broaden the cuisine so it extends out much further than Italy.

PP: Absolutely, this truly has a much more international feel.

WF: We have chefs from all over the world: Austria, New Zealand, Dominican Republic, Peru, Malaysia, and Italy all bringing their particular knowledge and skills to the table and therefore infusing our cuisine with a wide range of flavors.

CV: Every time we need to hire another chef we always try to bring somebody who can bring new ideas to our restaurant.

PP: So with that wide of a variety of backgrounds in your chefs, how do you design your menu?

CV: It’s exciting because the menu is always evolving. We established ourselves with some “must haves” on the menu and these items will not change; however we are constantly tweaking the menu: adding new dishes and maybe taking out some dishes that we do not feel work so well.  Collaboration between all the chefs is the key for the creation of our dinner menu.

WF: Cris and I are the creators of our menu.  The reason why we have such a multiethnic kitchen is because this allows us to come up with many different authentic dishes, done by the chef with the right experience.  One example is the ceviche: we wanted to have ceviches on our menu but in the beginning we were not happy and we decided to hire a Peruvian chef (ceviche is originally from Peru) and now we think we have the best ceviche on island.

PP: We agree, your ceviche is outstanding.  In fact, we understand you were the first to bring it to Cayman, so thanks!  Also your Tuna tartar is delicious!  Who heads up your kitchen?

CV: Our kitchen is headed up by Executive Chef Marc Benkoe.  He is from Austria where he attended culinary school.  After few years working in his country he moved to Grand Cayman six years ago.  He has been with us since the start.  We are very happy about our kitchen staff, we just recently added Mook to our kitchen brigade.  He is from New Zealand but he spent a lot of time in Vancouver Canada.  Together with Paolo from Firenze Italy (his pastas are amazing…) and Yango our Malesian chef, who has over 40 years experience in the kitchen (you definitely don’t want to miss one of his mouth watering Asian specials) and the rest of the team (Rene', Jippy, Willie and Phillip) they form an amazing talented brigade.

PP: You are known for your outstanding fresh seafood.  How did that develop?

WF: We always believed quality is the key of any restaurant’s success.  We always buy the freshest local catch or the top quality from the market.

PP: Your Sunday brunch is something that many of our passengers continue to rave about.

CV:Agua’s brunch reflects our extended regular menu, and goes from typically Italian recipes like Homemade Lasagna, Carpaccio, Seafood Salad, Cold Cuts and Cheeses to Asian dishes like Beef RanDang, Hummus, Babaganus, Sushi and Sashimi.  We also serve Peruvian Ceviche and Tiradito, Blue Point Oysters, Spanish Paella, Beef Wellinton and many other dishes.  Do not get too full!!!  You must try our homemade Dessert: Tiramisu, Chocolate Mousse, Fruit Tart, Bomboloni, Semifreddo, Profiteroles and Fresh Fruit.

PP: So what do you like to do when you can find some time off?

CV: I love to spend time with my beautiful wife and our 20 month old son, Sergio.

WF:  For me it is easy to find me up at Barker, kitesurfing.  In fact, I love kitesurfing so much that I also own Kitesurf Cayman, a kitesurf school.

PP: So with the tough competition in the restaurant business how do you keep attracting the locals?

WF: Well of course the quality of the food is the main thing but we always try to make it interesting coming up with different ideas; one example is that for the slower season we had a tasting menu every night that changed every week.  We also have different theme nights, just last week we had a Chef from Spain (Jesus Ramiro ) who owns a Michelin Star restaurant and a winery in Valladolid coming to Agua to work with our staff to create a Spanish Night.  It was a great dinner, we had the chance to work with liquid nitrogen, this is very trendy back in Spain and it was a great experience for our Chef Marc and the rest of the guys.

PP: You mentioned your team, your staff.  They seem to share your same unique sense of warmth and hospitality.

WF: That’s very important to us.  We’re very proud of our staff, most of our guys have been with us since the start.  When we hire new people we want to make sure they understand our ideas.  If we think they wouldn’t fit with the rest of the team, we don’t hire them.  Competition is continually getting tougher in Cayman’s restaurant business, but, judging by our happy customers, we think we are on the right track at Agua.

CV: To show how important our customers are, Agua provides every day a full Gluten Free, Vegetarian and Vegan Menu.  To assure that top level of customer service, one of the two of us is always here.  People know they can talk directly to us.  When we opened in 2009, people thought we were crazy, but we’re happy to keep doing what we’re doing.  The goal is to create great food, and for people to leave happy.

PP: And from what our passenger’s tell us, they certainly are!

Agua Restaurant & Lounge
Gateway Plaza
(345) 949-2482


Pick of the Month Archive:

Pick Of The Month 2011

Pick Of The Month 2012

Pick Of The Month 2013

Pick Of The Month 2014

Guy Harvey's Island Grill 2015

Tortuga Rum Company 2015

Tiki Beach 2015

Agua Restaurant & Lounge 2015

Red Sail Sports 2015

Eagle Rays Bar and Grill 2015

Cayman In A Nutshell 2015

KARoo 2015

Eden Rock Diving Center 2015

Abacus 2015

Michael's Genuine Food & Drink 2015

SNUBA Cayman 2015

Capt. Marvin’s Watersports 2015

Copper Falls Steakhouse 2015

Discover Scuba Diving with Red Sail 2015

Catch Restaurant & Lounge 2015

Capt. Marvin’s Watersports 2015

Lobster Pot Restaurant & Wine Bar 2015

Tukka Restaurant and Bar 2015

Cayman Kayaks 2015

The Jolly Roger 2015

Catch Restaurant & Lounge 2015

Guy Harvey's Island Grill 2016

Eden Rock Diving Center 2016

The Bistro 2016

Paradise Sailing & Snorkeling 2016

Agua Restaurant & Lounge 2016

Red Sail Sports 2016

Cayman In A Nutshell 2016

Eagle Rays Bar and Grill 2016

The Jolly Roger 2016

Grand Old House 2016

Capt. Marvin’s Watersports 2016

Osetra Bay 2016

Copper Falls Steakhouse 2016

Discover Scuba Diving with Red Sail 2016

Capt. Marvin’s Watersports 2016

Catch Restaurant & Lounge 2016

Cimboco 2016

Lobster Pot Restaurant & Wine Bar 2016

Tukka Restaurant and Bar 2016

Cayman Kayaks 2016

Cayman In A Nutshell 2016

Guy Harvey's Island Grill 2016

Catch Restaurant & Lounge 2017

Queen Elizabeth II Botanic Park 2017

The Bistro 2017

Red Sail Sports 2017

Agua Restaurant & Lounge 2017

Cayman In A Nutshell 2017

Eagle Rays Bar and Grill 2017

Eden Rock Diving Center 2017

Cimboco 2017

Casa 43 2017

Pedro St James 2017

Agua Restaurant & Lounge 2017

Capt. Marvin’s Watersports 2017

Copper Falls Steakhouse 2017

SNUBA Cayman 2017

Lobster Pot Restaurant & Wine Bar 2017

Eden Rock Diving Center 2017

Tukka Restaurant and Bar 2017

Divetech 2017

Eden Rock Diving Center 2017

Catch Restaurant & Lounge 2017

Red Sail Sports 2018

Guy Harvey's Island Grill 2018